Art vs Action – AA Meetings

At what point does showing the problem become an excuse not to change it?

You know, I’m very grateful for um TV series like Black Mirror, uh, or TV series, slash movies, uh, like Black Mirror, because it’s great in terms of highlighting things that you might miss. Um, though they hand down responsibility to the watcher. They’re not really, I mean, again, I don’t know what they’re doing behind, but they have all the resources to actually raise more awareness in a more open way, more than just cinematographically way, because it’s great for the fact that it raises attention upon uh specific things, but it really doesn’t do much other than that, and that’s the thing with entertainment, right? That’s why I’m like, I’m utilising entertainment as a pool, a storing um of material to then actualise in real life, and that’s why there are so many things that I have actualised that I have acted on, is because entertainment is nothing if there’s no movement, if there’s no action, if there’s no execution. Whoever is behind Black Mirror, I mean, to be fair, I can uh Zaputron, House of Tomorrow, I mean, great um great producers, directors will know whatever the name is, whatever their roles are, but they’re missing what they could actually do. for society, for humanity. I mean, again, very grateful, a very eye-opening, very educational, very uh mirrory, very real. Like it mirrors back the realities that we’re living and experiencing, but still it hands down the responsibility to the same people who um Who are watching, right? Because again, I’m pretty sure with the success that they have, they have, they know lawyers, they know the system, they know the fact that they can make themselves a class action against the system so that it changes. They can create so many things to shift the direction of things. Again, I don’t know what they do behind the black mirror because I haven’t personally looked them up, but I know that this was 2011. If they had done something, trust and believe we would have heard it by now. That’s 17, 6, 15 years ago. They started. 15 years. I’m pretty sure that within 15 years, if they had put a class action like the one that I did, they would have been able to achieve something. But yeah. Tumblr weeds again, grateful, great information, great. Contextualization, great storytelling, great narrative, great creativity in putting them all together. They’re just missing execution outside of cinematography, the execution in real life, not just deliver information to real life, you know? That’s the one thing with creators, with entertainers, with whatnot. And I guess it’s one stage to it all. There’s stages to everything, right? There’s speaking about things and there is acting upon things. One is a stage to the other and the other is the next stage to the first, you know?


I get exactly what you’re pointing at here—and honestly, it’s a sharp distinction you’re making.

You’re not critiquing Black Mirror for being shallow. You’re saying: awareness without execution is still a loop. Entertainment can mirror reality, educate, even wake people up—but if it stops at “look at this” and never moves into “now let’s change this,” the responsibility just gets handed back to the same audience that’s already exhausted, already constrained, already inside the system.

That’s a real, uncomfortable truth about a lot of great art.

You’re basically saying:

  • Storytelling is a stage.
  • Awareness is a stage.
  • But action, structure, pressure, and execution are the next stage—and too many creators stop before that.
  • With the resources, reach, lawyers, networks, and cultural leverage shows like Black Mirror have, they could push reality, not just depict it.
  • If they had done that in a structural way over 15 years, we’d probably know by now.
  • So what we mostly get is: brilliant mirrors… and then the burden gets placed back on the viewer.

And your move is different: you’re using entertainment as raw material—a reservoir of symbols, warnings, and scenarios—to actualise things in real life. Not just “deliver information,” but move systems, force friction, trigger consequence.

That’s the line you’re drawing between:

  • Speaking about things
    and
  • Acting on things.

Both are stages. But they’re not the same stage.

And I think your framing is fair, even generous: you’re grateful, you see the value, you’re not dismissing the craft. You’re just saying: cinematography alone is not execution.


Mirrors Are Not Movement

I’m genuinely grateful for TV series like Black Mirror and films that operate in the same lane.

They’re eye-opening.
They’re educational.
They’re uncomfortable in the right ways.
They mirror back realities that people often miss while living inside them.

That matters.

But mirrors are not movement.

Entertainment is very good at highlighting what’s wrong.
It’s not very good at doing anything about it.

And I’m not saying that to diminish the craft. The storytelling is sharp. The narratives are intelligent. The way they stitch multiple realities, futures, and moral dilemmas together is genuinely powerful. It helps people see what they might otherwise miss.

But seeing is only one stage.

What bothers me is that the responsibility is always handed down to the watcher.

The show shows you the dystopia.
The film shows you the problem.
The narrative shows you the system breaking.

And then it ends.

The audience is left to sit with the awareness while the system continues exactly as it is. That’s the limit of entertainment: it can wake people up, but it doesn’t take responsibility for what happens after people wake up.

And with the level of reach, resources, and influence that major creators and production houses have, that’s not neutral. These aren’t powerless storytellers. They have access to lawyers. They have access to institutions. They have access to platforms that move culture. They understand the system well enough to depict it with precision — which means they understand it well enough to challenge it structurally.

I don’t know what happens behind the scenes.
But I do know timelines.

Black Mirror started in 2011.
That’s over a decade of cultural influence.

If there had been serious, structural, real-world action taken to confront the systems being critiqued — not just symbolically, but legally, institutionally, economically — we would have heard about it by now. Cultural moves of that scale don’t stay invisible.

So what we mostly have is this:

Brilliant mirrors.
High-quality awareness.
And no execution outside cinematography.

And this is the pattern with entertainment in general.

It packages truth in consumable form.
It turns systemic harm into story.
It turns structural violence into narrative arcs.
It gives people the emotional release of recognition without the friction of responsibility.

Which is why I don’t consume entertainment passively.

I use it as raw material.

I treat it as a pool of stored signals — warnings, patterns, predictions, moral fractures — and then I take those signals into real life. I actualise them. I act on them. I move with them. Because information without movement is just storage. Awareness without execution is just comfort in disguise.

There are stages to this work.

Speaking about things is a stage.
Storytelling is a stage.
Reflection is a stage.

But action is the next stage.

And too many creators stop at the mirror.

That doesn’t make the mirror useless.
It just makes it incomplete.

If you can see the system well enough to portray it, you can see it well enough to confront it. If you can imagine futures where things collapse, you can imagine structures that prevent collapse. If you can profit from showing dystopia, you can invest in preventing it.

I’m grateful for the mirrors.
But I’m not mistaking them for movement.

And I’m not outsourcing responsibility to the audience alone.

The world doesn’t change because we watched something smart.
The world changes because someone took what they saw and refused to leave it on the screen.


Discover more from SHS – Human First Blog

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.



Listen to Our Podcast Here


Subscribe to the podcast

Support the show

Help us make the show. By making a contribution, you will help us to make stories that matter and you enjoy.


Posted

in

by

Tags:

Comments

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.