22–32 minutes

2315: POWER BACK TO THE PEOPLE: WHAT HAPPENS WHEN DEMAND, NOT CAPITALISM, ORGANISES THE ECONOMY?

What happens when we stop organising an economy around who can capture the most customers, charge the most money, buy the most companies and create the strongest demand, and instead organise it around the demand that actually exists?

Because that is the fundamental shift.

The people do not need companies to manufacture a reason to buy something.

The people already have needs.

They already eat.
They already need clothes.
They already need housing.
They already need transport.
They already need healthcare.
They already need education.
They already want things that improve the quality of their lives.

So why is so much of the economy built around convincing people what they should want, where they should buy it, which brand they should trust and how much more they should be prepared to pay for essentially the same resource?

What happens when the economic system starts from a much simpler premise:

People express demand → government measures collective demand → government maps available resources → government determines provisioning requirements → organisations provide → results are measured against the original demand.

That is not government telling people what they need.

It is government finally finding out what they need.

And there is a massive difference.

DEMAND SHOULD COME BEFORE SUPPLY

Demand tells the system what is required.

Supply tells the system what is possible.

Governance coordinates the two.

That should be the economic relationship.

Instead, capitalism has developed mechanisms where supply can become powerful enough to shape demand itself.

Companies market products.
Brands create identities around products.
Products are positioned as necessities.
Consumers are psychologically separated from alternatives.
Competition becomes a battle for market share.
And the winner is often the one that can capture the most of the demand rather than the one that simply provides the best thing.

What if we stopped treating the customer as something to capture?

What if the customer was simply the source of the demand?

That would immediately change the role of the provider.

A company would not need to manufacture demand to survive.

It would need to respond to demand.

And that means the economy starts becoming geographical and functional rather than reputational.

SAME PRODUCT. SAME PRICE.

Imagine buying the same product in different parts of the country and finding the same standardised price.

Not because every provider is identical.

Because the price of the product has been separated from which company happens to be selling it.

Provider A is not allowed to say:

“We are the prestigious brand, therefore ours is £15.”

Provider B cannot say:

“We dominate this area, therefore ours is £18.”

Provider C cannot say:

“We spent millions marketing this product, so the customer now has to pay for the marketing.”

The product has a recognised price.

The providers provide it.

That means the consumer is no longer primarily choosing according to who managed to persuade them most effectively to spend more money.

They are choosing according to what actually matters.

Quality.

Reliability.

Ingredients.

Durability.

Health.

Accessibility.

Service.

Workmanship.

Environmental impact.

Innovation.

Consistency.

Availability.

And suddenly, the competitive field changes.

COMPANIES WOULD HAVE TO COMPETE ON WHAT ACTUALLY MATTERS

This is where competition can become useful rather than simply destructive.

There is no reason to eliminate competition.

There is a reason to change what companies compete over.

If the price is the same, then the customer can finally ask:

Which product is actually better?

Take food.

Imagine two suppliers selling the same broad category of produce for the same standard price.

One produces using methods that damage soil and rely heavily on toxic inputs.

Another invests in healthier production methods, better soil management and better-quality produce.

The second should have the ability to distinguish itself through that quality.

The customer chooses it because of what it provides, not because it manipulated the price, outspent everyone on advertising or created artificial prestige around the brand.

That is a much more meaningful competition.

And it creates an incentive to improve.

The company doesn’t need to make the customer think:

“You need this.”

It needs to make the customer think:

“This is genuinely better.”

That is an entirely different economic relationship.

SPECIALISATION WOULD FINALLY HAVE A PURPOSE

And this is where another huge change comes in.

Why does one company need to keep expanding into everything?

Why does a company that is exceptionally good at one thing need to become a conglomerate simply because the economic system rewards accumulation?

We already understand specialisation intuitively.

A butcher can specialise in meat.

A chocolate factory can specialise in chocolate.

A furniture company can specialise in furniture.

A technology company can specialise in a particular technological field.

And there is a reason this matters.

The butcher may know meat better than a general commercial supermarket.

The chocolate factory may produce better chocolate than a general sweet and candy company that happens to have a chocolate line.

That does not make the larger company evil and the smaller company virtuous.

It simply means specialisation can produce expertise.

So why not organise industries accordingly?

One company becomes excellent at one thing.

Another becomes excellent at another.

Another develops another variation.

Then the companies can form partnerships instead of endlessly swallowing one another.

One specialises in production.

Another specialises in packaging.

Another in distribution.

Another in refrigeration.

Another in technology.

Another in research.

Another in repair.

And instead of one giant corporation eventually controlling every part of the chain, industries become networks of specialists.

That is levelling the playing field.

STOP BUYING YOUR WAY INTO EVERY INDUSTRY

There is also a category of company behaviour that would have to disappear.

The company whose original business is one thing, but then keeps buying businesses completely unrelated to its original purpose simply because it has accumulated enough capital to do so.

That should not automatically be treated as the natural destination of success.

Success should not mean:

“I have enough money, therefore I am now entitled to own everything adjacent to the economy.”

There should be a difference between expanding capability and accumulating control.

A company that becomes better at what it does should be rewarded for being better at what it does.

A company that wants to develop a new specialist area should be able to do so where it can genuinely provide something valuable.

But endlessly buying unrelated industries creates concentration of power.

And once concentration becomes large enough, it stops being about providing.

It becomes about controlling provision.

Those are two completely different things.

THE PEOPLE SHOULDN’T NEED TO PAY MORE TO GET BETTER QUALITY

This is another consequence of standardised pricing.

In today’s economic logic, quality can become a luxury.

The person with more money gets better food.

Better housing.

Better healthcare.

Better products.

Better environments.

Better options.

The person without money is told to accept whatever is affordable.

That creates an absurd hierarchy in which quality itself becomes concentrated.

Why?

Why should human beings have access to different levels of dignity simply because their purchasing power differs?

There can be differences in timing, availability or preference.

But the highest possible standard should be the direction of the entire system.

If a higher standard has been achieved, why would society deliberately maintain a lower standard when everyone could eventually have access to the higher one?

There should not be a company saying:

“We have figured out how to make this healthier, safer and better, but we are going to keep providing the inferior version because the market will pay for it.”

The discovery of a higher standard should begin a process of moving the whole system towards it.

QUALITY SHOULD BECOME A STANDARD, NOT A PREMIUM

This is where innovation becomes genuinely interesting.

Imagine a company discovers a radically better manufacturing method.

It is healthier.

More durable.

More efficient.

Less wasteful.

Less harmful.

More effective.

Instead of simply charging whatever it wants because it has discovered something better, the company could present the new method for assessment.

The system examines:

What does it cost?

What resources does it require?

What quality has actually been achieved?

How many people depend upon the product?

What are the consequences of adopting it?

Can it be replicated?

What would implementation require?

And then the new quality can become a recognised standard.

The company that discovered it gets recognition.

The workers who created it get recognition.

The industry gets a new benchmark.

And companies that implement the standard can then provide that standard themselves.

Eventually the improved method becomes normal.

Then the system looks for the next improvement.

That means innovation does not just create another luxury tier.

Innovation upgrades the common standard.

That is a completely different incentive.

Instead of:

“Can we invent something better and charge rich people more for it?”

the incentive becomes:

“Can we create something better that eventually improves what everyone receives?”

NOT EVERY PROVIDER WILL HAVE THE SAME CAPACITY

And this is where the model becomes practical rather than idealistic.

Suppose there are two companies supplying the same product.

Company A has enough resources to refill a store four times a week.

Company B can only refill it once.

Why immediately close Company B?

The system already knows there is a geographical demand.

Company B has a role.

Its capacity is simply different.

So the allocation system can structure the demand accordingly.

Company A provides the continuity.

Company B provides its allocated quantity.

And in the time between those production cycles, Company B can work on improving its standard, developing a better version, improving efficiency or contributing to another part of the production chain.

That is far more intelligent than pretending every company needs to operate identically.

The goal is not identical companies.

The goal is coordinated capacity.

And if Company B eventually discovers how to produce a superior version or increase its capacity, the whole system benefits from that discovery.

ALLOCATION CREATES STABILITY

This is one of the strongest parts of the model.

If companies have a known allocation of demand, they know what they are expected to provide.

That means they have something that conventional markets often make unpredictable:

structured demand.

A company might know:

“We are responsible for producing X amount for this geographical area every week.”

Now it can calculate:

How many workers are needed.

How much manufacturing capacity is required.

How much raw material is needed.

How much energy is needed.

How much transport is needed.

How much storage is required.

How much maintenance is required.

How much money is required to keep that operation stable.

That changes salaries too.

Because suddenly the business is not constantly guessing whether next month’s revenue will collapse because another company started a price war.

There is a known provisioning responsibility.

There is known demand.

There is known capacity.

And therefore there can be known staffing requirements.

THE SAME PRINCIPLE SHOULD APPLY TO SALARIES

The salary system can follow the same logic.

You don’t need one person earning millions while another person working equally essential hours cannot afford basic life.

You also don’t need every salary to be identical.

Different responsibilities, skills, qualifications, working conditions and contributions can still be recognised.

But salaries should be designed around the value and requirements of the role rather than simply the bargaining power of whoever controls the organisation.

And when the organisation has structured demand, its workforce requirement becomes much easier to calculate.

That makes labour far more predictable.

You know what the company has to provide.

You know how much production is required.

You know how many people are needed.

You know the approximate cost of maintaining that operation.

You know what wages are necessary.

You know what resources are required.

The business can therefore plan around people rather than repeatedly treating people as the easiest variable to cut.

COST CUTTING SHOULD NOT MEAN AUTOMATICALLY CUTTING PEOPLE

This is where the model directly challenges the normal logic of redundancies.

If a company discovers that it can produce the required quantity at a lower cost, that saving should not automatically become:

“Fire people.”

Why should human beings be the first cost to remove?

The information goes back into the system.

The government assesses the saving.

Then the money can be allocated into contingency reserves.

It could support staff.

Repay loans.

Cover future expenses.

Fund new research.

Upgrade infrastructure.

Protect the organisation during future fluctuations.

Or, where appropriate, eventually increase wages.

And that last part matters.

Because if a company has genuinely become more efficient and the system confirms that the saving is sustainable, one possible outcome is that more money can go into the workforce.

More workers have more disposable income.

More workers can spend that money on their own needs.

That money circulates.

The economy gains purchasing power without requiring an entirely new artificial demand mechanism.

The objective becomes:

Either value your teams more, or use the resources you have created to achieve even higher quality.

Not:

“How many people can we remove before the spreadsheet looks better?”

CONTINUITY OF HUMAN LIFE SHOULD BE A RESOURCE PRIORITY

This is where the entire concept ultimately becomes much more human.

A company is not just a collection of numbers.

Its workers have lives.

Its customers have lives.

Its suppliers have lives.

Its geographical community has lives.

If a specific company is responsible for an economic function on which thousands of people depend, that company should not simply be allowed to disappear because another organisation has technically captured more market share.

The system should assess the dependencies.

Who relies on this provider?

What does it provide?

What happens to the geographical area if it disappears?

Can another provider cover the demand?

How long would the transition take?

Can the company be restructured instead?

Can its workforce be reassigned?

Can it specialise?

Can it partner?

Can it become part of another provider network?

That is how you prevent monopoly without turning every failed company into a protected institution.

The question is not:

“Must this company survive?”

The question is:

“How do we preserve human continuity while changing who provides the function?”

That is a much more intelligent question.

FAILURE SHOULD ALSO BE MANAGED DIFFERENTLY

If a provider cannot demonstrate that it can fulfil its assigned demand, that should not immediately mean thousands of workers lose their livelihoods.

The system can intervene.

Aid can be provided.

Demand can be redistributed.

Another provider can assist.

A partnership can be created.

Production can be transferred.

The workforce can be retained while the organisational structure changes.

The objective is not to preserve incompetence.

The objective is to stop organisational failure from automatically becoming human failure.

There is a massive distinction between those two things.

GOVERNMENT SHOULD BE THE COORDINATOR OF RESOURCES

And this is where the economic argument returns directly to governance.

What should government actually be about?

Not merely governing people.

Not merely announcing policies.

Not merely reacting when systems break.

Not merely distributing money after people have already fallen through the gaps.

Government should be the provider of governance and public infrastructure.

Government should coordinate the resources necessary to satisfy collectively expressed human requirements.

That means knowing:

What people need.

Where they need it.

How much they need.

What resources exist.

Who can provide them.

Who depends on them.

What capacity exists.

Where there are shortages.

Where there is duplication.

Where there is waste.

Where there is concentration.

Where there is vulnerability.

Where a better organisation would produce a better outcome.

Government becomes the coordinator between demand and supply.

Not the owner of everything.

Not the enemy of business.

Not the servant of capital.

The coordinator.

RESOURCES SHOULD RESPOND TO HUMANITY

This is the part that brings everything together.

Resources should respond to humanity rather than humanity being organised around whoever controls the resources.

At present, having money can mean access.

Having ownership can mean access.

Having capital can mean access.

Having influence can mean access.

Having a dominant company can mean access.

Having a powerful institution can mean access.

But the human need itself can disappear underneath all of that.

Someone can need something desperately and still not have the economic power to register that need.

That is the distortion.

A demand-based system begins somewhere else.

It asks:

What is actually required?

Then:

What resources are available?

Then:

What is the best way to organise those resources?

Then:

Who can provide it?

Then:

How well did they provide it?

Then:

What can be improved?

That is governance.

THIS IS ALSO WHERE AI COULD ACTUALLY BE USEFUL

There is another part of this that I think is particularly obvious.

We already have enormous amounts of data.

Companies already know what products cost to manufacture.

They know material costs.

Labour costs.

Transport costs.

Energy costs.

Packaging costs.

Storage costs.

Production volumes.

Waste.

Returns.

Maintenance.

Sales.

Capacity.

Demand patterns.

Geographical differences.

And so on.

The question is whether humanity can actually bring enough of that information together to understand what a product should reasonably cost.

This is one place where AI could be extremely useful.

Not as the decision-maker.

Not as the government.

Not as the replacement for human judgment.

As the machine that can process enormous quantities of information that human beings cannot realistically calculate manually at the same speed.

We could upload the relevant data.

Find the lowest production cost.

Find the highest.

Find the average.

Understand why the differences exist.

Factor in quality.

Factor in labour.

Factor in resource use.

Factor in geographical requirements.

Factor in the number of people depending on the product.

Factor in long-term sustainability.

Factor in infrastructure.

Factor in contingencies.

And then produce a proposed standardised figure for human governance to assess.

Maybe that is one of the things AI was actually supposed to be for.

Not deciding humanity’s future.

Counting humanity’s information.

Humans decide what the information means.

Machines help us calculate what humans cannot reasonably calculate alone.

PRICING SHOULD BE TESTED, NOT ASSUMED

And the pricing itself should be tested.

You could trial a proposed standard price.

Then survey people.

What would humanity actually be prepared to pay?

Does the proposed figure create accessibility?

Does it sustain provision?

Does it fairly cover production?

Does it create unnecessary surplus?

Does it prevent access?

Does it encourage better quality?

Does it create geographical inequality?

Does it produce shortages?

Does it create waste?

Then the system adjusts.

Pricing becomes something that can be measured and improved rather than something companies simply impose because the market allows them to.

And once the price becomes more homogeneous, competition is pushed back towards what actually matters.

THE GEOGRAPHICAL ECONOMY

This also creates an interesting new way of understanding supply.

Instead of:

“Which brand can capture this market?”

the question becomes:

“Where is the demand, and who can best fulfil it?”

That means supply becomes more geographical.

A provider does not necessarily need to dominate a national market.

It can serve a geographical area.

Another provider can serve another.

Another can specialise in a particular type of product.

Another can cover shortages.

Another can handle surge demand.

The system can allocate according to geography, capacity and specialisation.

That creates resilience.

One organisation failing does not necessarily collapse the entire supply chain.

There are other providers.

There are partnerships.

There is redundancy.

There is contingency.

There is knowledge of exactly what each part is responsible for.

And because the providers are not primarily competing on price, there is much less incentive to destroy one another simply to acquire the customer.

DEMAND BECOMES THE ORGANISING LANGUAGE OF THE ECONOMY

This is what I think the model ultimately becomes.

Not:

capital decides supply.

Not:

companies manufacture demand.

Not:

customers chase prices.

Not:

the largest corporation absorbs the smaller ones.

Instead:

Demand tells the system what is required.
Supply tells the system what is possible.
Governance coordinates the two.

That gives everybody a role.

Humanity establishes need and priority.

Government coordinates resources and infrastructure.

Providers specialise in delivering.

Workers create the actual value.

Technology increases capability.

AI helps process the information.

And the system continuously measures whether what was provided actually matched what humanity asked for.

That final part is crucial.

Because the system should always be able to look back and ask:

Did we provide what people said they needed?

Not:

Did the company hit its quarterly target?

Not:

Did the shareholders get the return they expected?

Not:

Did we successfully manufacture enough desire for the product?

But:

Did humanity’s demand become fulfilled?

AND WHEN SOMETHING BETTER IS DISCOVERED, EVERYONE SHOULD BENEFIT

If there is a higher standard, the system should move towards it.

If there is a safer process, adopt it.

If there is a healthier method, adopt it.

If there is a more durable material, adopt it.

If there is a more efficient technology, integrate it.

If one company discovers it, recognise that company.

Recognise the workers.

Recognise the innovation.

Then make the innovation available for the wider system to adopt.

Eventually everyone reaches that standard.

Then the competition starts again.

What can be better than this?

That is how you create an economy that continuously improves without requiring people to be deliberately left behind.

There should not be one provider holding back the quality that another human being could have simply because some customers cannot afford the premium version.

The highest achievable standard should be the destination.

Differences can exist in timing.

Different providers can have different capacities.

Different regions can receive different quantities according to demand.

But the direction should remain the same:

Highest possible quality for all.

THIS IS HOW YOU LEVEL THE PLAYING FIELD

The playing field is not level when one company can spend billions convincing people that its version is superior before the product has even demonstrated that it is.

The playing field is not level when one corporation can buy competitors.

It is not level when one company controls the supply chain.

It is not level when price is used to exclude people from quality.

It is not level when salaries are dictated almost entirely by bargaining power.

It is not level when efficiency means redundancies.

It is not level when money determines whether a person’s demand even counts.

It is not level when companies are incentivised to expand beyond their expertise simply because capital rewards accumulation.

A level playing field would look different.

Same recognised price.

Transparent standards.

Specialised providers.

Structured geographical demand.

Stable allocations.

Fairly organised salaries.

Protection against unnecessary concentration.

Competition through quality.

Innovation through improvement.

Partnership instead of endless acquisition.

Government coordination rather than corporate capture.

And a system capable of showing exactly where the resources are going.

That is not removing business.

It is removing the ability of business to become the owner of human demand.

And that is a very different proposition.

POWER BACK TO THE PEOPLE

The whole point is not to create another system where the government simply replaces the corporation as the authority that tells everyone what to do.

That would just be another concentration of power.

The point is to change the starting position.

The people are the source of the demand.

The providers respond to that demand.

Government coordinates the resources required to fulfil it.

Companies compete on how well they fulfil their role.

Workers are treated as part of the continuity of the system rather than as disposable numbers.

Innovation raises the common standard rather than becoming a luxury reserved for whoever can pay the most.

And when something new becomes possible, it is incorporated as homogeniously as possible across the system rather than remaining locked behind whoever discovered it.

Because resources do not exist for the resources.

Companies do not exist for companies.

Government does not exist for government.

The economy does not exist for the economy.

They exist to organise the resources of humanity around the requirements of humanity.

That is what power back to the people actually starts to mean.

Not giving people another opportunity to choose between competing corporations.

Not merely letting people vote every few years.

Not giving consumers more brands to choose from.

But giving humanity a genuine role in determining what the system is actually organised to provide in the first place.

Because once you know exactly what the demand is, you can finally see what is actually needed.

And once you know what is actually needed, you can organise the resources around it.

And once the resources are organised around humanity rather than whoever controls the most capital, the entire economic relationship changes.

People express the need.
Providers fulfil the need.
Governance coordinates the system.
Innovation raises the standard.
And nobody gets to own the demand itself.

That is the playing field I am talking about levelling.

….

Great write about this cause even the new focuses are foundamental, as finally people will value qualitg over just pricing and the people will be able to find the exact same pricing everywhere, meaning the supply it’s more geographical than reputational.

And competition is on the things that natter as it would force comoanies to see how best to create per example heslthy produce without toxic fertilisers as it would have the customer choose that soecifci product. Here we also incentivise company partnerships, where one focuses on a version of a product and the other on another, making industries specislised and have one comoany focus on one thing at the time isntead of just numbers across multiple products. We know the butchers mest is betrer than commmercial stores, and that a chocolate dactory does better chocolat rhan a sweet and candy factory doing chocolate. Put specialisation in the right places organisinng everyone ariund what they do best. Levelling the olain field.

Same goes foe salaries.

And j lovw rge wllofarion one cause it allows comoanies who might get closed by monopoly to have selected quantities ti civer at all tine, creating structured and stable company demand, which levels the peoblem of salaries and manufafturing costs, allowing to kniw exactly how much woukd be covered ar any given moment in time.

And if one discovers it can do it for less, they must relate the information to the government that rules it, and allocate that money for contingency pots for all staff per example or repaying loans, or covering future expenses or as last resort a raise for everyone which puts more money in the economy as more employess will have more to spend accordingly to the raise for their own needs. The goal shoukd be you either value more your teams or you invest in even better quality. No need to have billionaires and those who struggle for either access to quakitg as overpriced or lack of money to actaully pay for their needs.

I love this part: People express needs and priorities → government measures collective demand → government maps available resources → government determines provisioning requirements → organisations provide → results are measured against the original demand.

This is what a government should be abojt: provider of governance and public infrastructure.

Government wouldn’t merely govern people.
It would govern the coordination of resources needed to satisfy collectively expressed human requirements.

Cause knowing exactly what the demand is, instead of creating demand allows a clear oversifht on what’s actually needed and not what’s wanted to be needed.

Resources respond to humanity rather than humanity being organised around whoever controls the resources.

This also helps avoid unjustified firing or redundancies when the aim is cost cutting as humanity and its healthy continuity becomes the main priority.

And as the demand decides if one cannot show it can provide or provide to the demand assigned, they then get aid from government as there’s people who might depend on that specific company’s economyp

Innovation follows demand and perfectionism, as if one can create better quality it is incentivised by it as they woukd open a new form of product, and pricing can follow a generalised quality framwork instead of the conoany assigning the price, it coukd offer the justification for a new qualitg offered to the market and the government making that the standard for that specific creation, mesning everyone that applies that specific quality or method, will have to be the demand to the supply of the conoany that brought it, to cover the b2b and also give recognition to the workers who created and achieved a new stanrdard. After a whike when everyone inplements it, everyone can continue providing whilst looking at achieving a new standard. If therw’s a higher standard there shouldn’t be a reasin to provide a lower standard, instead all resources should go to the highsst srandard for all to all.

There shouldn’t be one thst holds back the quality that a customer coukd gef, just because rhey don’t want to aquire the higher srandard as evwryone deserves the highesr possible.

Or differentiate priorities. If one tskes longer to provide, then the concession would be on timing, but every lower sfandard must be relayed and justified, whilst providing the highest value and standard the geogrpahicak societt needs. If fheres 2 companies of fv, but one has resources to refill a store once a week and the orher 4 a week, then the one with the one per week shoukd use the time of production to akso work on the higher standard, as it then csn helo the one thst provides continuity and filling the time gaps.

Demand tells the system what is required.
Supply tells the system what is possible.
Governance coordinates the two.

And everytime there’s a new possibke, it shoukd be installed as homogeniously as possible.

As for the pricing we aleady know everything that’s needed and companies have the data if hiw much every product costs to make right now. The oal is to find out the average, the lowesr and the highest, whilst looking at what makes both and based on all aspects like quality and how many people depend on the sale of the final product, to construct w homogenous pricing. This is where ai can help hugely. We would just need to uoload all data and it is logivsk enough ti create the best numeircsk average tsking everytjing into account, as we woukd have to memorise all datas ij order for humans to pool the numbers snd fish the final one. Maybe that’s all AI was supposed to do, just count high number of data for the benefit of humanitt.

We woukd test run the pricing whilst also doing surveys as to what humanitt would actuslly pay for specific items.

There’s xompanies whao are trying to just stick to their lanes and rhere’s comoanies who keeo expanding and buying industries that have nothing to do wirh their original and main business, thst would need to stop.


Discover more from SHS – Human First Writings

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply



Listen to Our Podcast Here


Subscribe to the podcast

Support the show

Help us make the show. By making a contribution, you will help us to make stories that matter and you enjoy.


by

Comments

Leave a Reply