19–28 minutes

2319: THE BASIC HUMAN NEEDS ECONOMY

When human rights finally enter the economic system

There is a problem with the way humanity talks about human rights.

We talk about them legally.

We talk about them constitutionally.

We talk about them politically.

We write them into legislation.

We place them into declarations.

We debate whether governments are respecting them.

But then we send the human being into an economy that can still say:

If you cannot pay, you cannot have it.

And that is where the whole thing starts to falter.

Because what is the practical value of a “right” to food if accessing food still fundamentally depends on purchasing power?

What is the practical meaning of the right to dignity if dignity becomes unaffordable?

What is the point of recognising housing as a human need while structuring housing around an economy that can price people out of having it?

A basic human right that has no corresponding economic infrastructure is only partially realised.

That is the gap SHS is trying to address.

HUMAN RIGHTS HAVE TO EXIST ECONOMICALLY TOO

We have created a strange separation.

The law says:

You have rights.

The economy says:

Can you afford them?

Those two statements cannot forever be treated as unrelated.

A human being needs food whether they have money or not.

A human being needs shelter whether they have capital or not.

A human being needs water whether they have purchasing power or not.

A child needs those things before they have ever earned a penny.

So why does the economic system get to behave as though the ability to pay is what makes the need real?

It shouldn’t.

That doesn’t mean every shop becomes free.

It doesn’t mean every product becomes free.

It doesn’t mean people stop working.

It doesn’t mean providers stop being paid.

It means we finally distinguish between:

what humanity needs in order to live

and

what humanity wants in order to expand the experience of living.

Those are not the same economic category.


HOMELESSNESS IS HUMAN LIVING

Everything beyond it is civilisation living.

That distinction has become particularly clear to me while experiencing social housing and temporary accommodation.

You suddenly see something that is often hidden when people are securely housed:

there is a difference between being alive and having the conditions civilisation has decided are necessary for a particular standard of life.

Food is fundamental.

Water is fundamental.

Shelter is fundamental.

Warmth is fundamental.

Hygiene is fundamental.

Sleep is fundamental.

Safety is fundamental.

Human connection is fundamental.

Everything civilisation builds beyond those foundations can then develop the quality, comfort, creativity and luxury of life.

But we have reversed the relationship.

We have made people earn the foundations before they are allowed to experience the civilisation built on top of them.

SHS is asking:

What happens when we guarantee the foundations first?


I JUST ATE A FULL BREAKFAST

I am sitting here having experienced something incredibly simple.

A full English breakfast.

The same sort of breakfast that could easily cost around £12 or more in many commercial settings.

Yet here, through the support environment I am currently in, I received it without paying for it directly.

And it immediately exposes something.

A human being does not stop needing food because they don’t currently have money.

The food still has to be produced.

Someone still has to grow it.

Someone has to process it.

Someone has to transport it.

Someone has to cook it.

Someone has to provide the building, equipment, energy and labour required to deliver it.

So “free” to the human being does not mean costless to society.

It means the economic burden is being organised somewhere else.

And that is the point.

We already know how to do this.

We are already capable of financing essential provision collectively.

The question is:

Why stop at emergency circumstances?


THE LESSON FROM SOCIAL SUPPORT

There is something very revealing about giving someone basic necessities without requiring immediate payment.

The person suddenly stops being treated primarily as a money machine.

They can eat.

They can sleep.

They can wash.

They can think.

They can begin organising their life.

And then the question becomes:

What can this human being now do with themselves?

That is a completely different starting point from:

How are they going to pay for survival?

And perhaps that is the economic mistake we have normalised.

We have made work responsible for financing existence before it is allowed to finance life beyond existence.


WORK SHOULD NOT BE THE PRICE OF BEING ALIVE

A child should never grow up learning:

“You have to submit to a system that doesn’t represent you before you can eat and have shelter.”

Those are the basic foundations of life.

A child didn’t choose the economic system.

A child didn’t create the housing market.

A child didn’t create monetary policy.

A child didn’t create capitalism.

A child didn’t decide how resources were allocated.

Yet somehow we construct a society where access to fundamental necessities is mediated by a system that the child has no capacity to consent to.

That is backwards.

And adults aren’t fundamentally different.

Becoming an adult should give you more agency over your life.

It should not mean:

Now you must spend the rest of your life proving that you deserve to exist.


THE GOVERNMENT ALREADY HAS PART OF THE MECHANISM

This is where SHS isn’t proposing something completely alien to existing government.

Governments already commission services.

They already fund providers.

They already allocate money for housing, healthcare, welfare and other forms of public provision.

The mechanism already exists.

SHS is asking:

What happens when we extend that logic deliberately to basic human needs?

Instead of giving a person money and telling them:

“Now go into the market and purchase your survival.”

the government could directly finance the provision of specified essential goods and services.

The person chooses from available provision.

The provider gets paid.

The human receives the necessity.

The economic transaction still occurs.

It simply doesn’t force the human being to personally carry the entire cost of maintaining their existence.


THAT DOESN’T MAKE EVERYTHING FREE

This distinction is crucial.

SHS is not proposing:

Everything is free.

There can still be shops.

There can still be businesses.

There can still be premium products.

There can still be luxury.

There can still be creativity.

There can still be entrepreneurial reward.

There can still be personal purchasing.

There can still be additional experiences people choose to finance themselves.

The distinction is:

Some things are so fundamental to human life that society should guarantee access to them.

A defined category of food.

Basic water.

Basic sanitation.

Basic shelter.

Essential energy.

Essential healthcare.

Essential education.

Possibly other categories that humanity identifies over time.

The list itself should not be frozen forever.

Human needs evolve.

Civilisation evolves.

Technology evolves.

So the definition of a basic human necessity should be continually reviewed.


THE PROVIDER STILL GETS PAID

This is where the model becomes economically interesting.

Suppose the government establishes that a certain category of food is a basic human provision.

The person doesn’t pay at the point of access.

But the producer doesn’t work for free.

The government finances the providers.

The provider produces.

The distributor distributes.

The worker gets paid.

The infrastructure gets maintained.

The human gets fed.

The transaction hasn’t disappeared.

It has been reorganised.

And because SHS is already proposing a demand-based economic model, government would have an even clearer picture of how much needs to be supplied.

People require a certain amount.

The system measures the demand.

Government knows the required quantity.

Providers are allocated production.

Providers are paid according to the agreed economic framework.

The human receives the necessity.

That is much more intelligent than making millions of individuals separately struggle to purchase the same essential resource.


DEMAND BECOMES VISIBLE

This is another huge advantage.

When a person has to buy food individually, purchasing power partially determines how much demand the economic system sees.

Someone who wants ten meals may be able to buy them.

Someone who needs ten meals but cannot afford them may effectively disappear from the market.

That is a terrible measurement system.

A demand-based public framework can ask:

How many people actually need food?

What food do they need?

Where do they need it?

How much?

At what quality?

How frequently?

Now government can commission the supply accordingly.

Instead of manufacturing demand through marketing, the system responds to the demand that already exists.


THE MONEY DOESN’T DISAPPEAR

This is important because someone will inevitably say:

“But where does the money come from?”

The same place economic money already comes from:

the wider economy.

The question isn’t whether resources have a cost.

The question is who carries that cost and how the cost is organised.

At present, a household may receive income and then individually pay for:

food,

housing,

energy,

transport,

healthcare,

education,

insurance,

and everything else.

SHS asks whether some of those costs could instead be organised collectively.

Government becomes the buyer.

Providers remain the suppliers.

Humanity becomes the beneficiary.

And the individual is freed to use their own economic activity for everything beyond the guaranteed basics.


THEN WORK CHANGES ITS PURPOSE

This is one of the biggest consequences.

What if a person worked because they wanted to finance:

a better home,

travel,

creative projects,

a business,

technology,

luxuries,

experiences,

greater comfort,

additional opportunities,

or simply more personal choice?

What if their salary didn’t first have to secure the basic right to eat and remain sheltered?

Then employment becomes more directly connected to what someone wants to build with their life.

Work is still valuable.

Contribution is still important.

People still need to participate.

But the economic pressure changes.

You are no longer saying:

Work or starve.

You are saying:

Your basic existence is protected. Now use your capacity to contribute, create, learn, innovate and experience the rest of life.

That could completely change how people relate to work.


AND IT CHANGES THE RELATIONSHIP WITH COMPANIES

A company doesn’t need to lose its purpose.

It gains a more predictable one.

Government knows there is a defined demand for essential provision.

Companies know there is a buyer.

The provider can calculate production.

Workers can be employed.

Resources can be ordered.

Infrastructure can be maintained.

Quality can be improved.

And the company doesn’t need to convince a person that they need food.

They already do.

That means the company can spend its energy making the food:

healthier,

safer,

better quality,

more sustainable,

more efficiently produced,

more locally appropriate,

or more enjoyable.

That is where competition belongs.

Not:

“Can we make the customer pay more?”

But:

“Can we provide something better?”


WHY THIS COULD REDUCE UNFAIR REDUNDANCIES

This also connects directly to the wider SHS economic model.

If demand is known, provider allocations can be known.

If allocations are known, production requirements can be known.

If production requirements are known, staffing requirements can be known.

If staffing requirements are known, the organisation can plan.

That reduces some of the uncertainty that currently makes human labour one of the easiest variables for organisations to cut when they need to change their numbers.

Instead of:

Revenue fell → cut workers

you can have:

Demand is known → provisioning is known → workforce requirement is known → resources are planned.

And when efficiency improves, the first question doesn’t have to be:

“Who can we fire?”

It can be:

“What should we do with the surplus?”

Improve wages.

Build contingency funds.

Repay borrowing.

Improve infrastructure.

Invest in quality.

Increase resilience.

Fund research.

Increase capacity.

There are many possibilities before destroying the workforce that helped create the efficiency.


BASIC NEEDS SHOULD NOT BECOME A LUXURY MARKET

There is another part of this that I find difficult to accept.

A human being can potentially pay radically different amounts for the same fundamental category of need depending on:

where they live,

who is selling it,

what brand it carries,

what marketing surrounds it,

what their income is,

and how much economic power they possess.

That means the person with more money can simply purchase access to a better standard.

And the person with less money is expected to compromise.

Why?

If humanity establishes that something is fundamental enough to guarantee, then the goal should be to make that provision good.

Not merely technically available.

A person shouldn’t have to choose between:

affordable but poor

and

excellent but unaffordable

when the resource concerned is fundamental to human life.


THIS IS WHERE THE UK HAS AN OPPORTUNITY

The UK’s departure from the EU changed the legal and institutional framework for external trade policy: while it was an EU member, trade policy in areas of EU competence was determined at EU level; after departure, the UK regained the ability to determine its own trade policy.

That creates policy space.

Whether someone regards Brexit itself as justified is a political question.

But the structural fact is straightforward:

Britain now has greater direct control over its own external trade policy than it had as an EU member.

That means the UK can demonstrate what it intends to do with that autonomy.

It can decide how it wants to organise trade.

How it wants to organise resources.

How it wants to support its people.

How it wants to work with other countries.

And whether sovereignty actually becomes self-application rather than simply another word for institutional independence.


THE EU EXAMPLE ALSO RAISES A DIFFERENT QUESTION

There is a factual correction worth making here because the frequently repeated figures can obscure the real issue.

The UK did pay substantial sums into the EU budget, but the claim that Britain was paying £90 billion a year and receiving £30 billion back is not supported by the House of Commons Library’s figures.

For example, the Library estimates that the UK’s average net public-sector contribution was around £7–£7.5 billion a year between 2016 and 2019 once EU receipts to UK organisations are included.

The more useful question, therefore, isn’t:

“Was the number £90 billion?”

It is:

What authority did membership transfer, what benefits did that arrangement create, what constraints accompanied it, and did those arrangements serve the UK’s own priorities?

EU membership involved shared competences and, in areas such as the customs union and international trade agreements, exclusive EU competence under the treaties.

That meant the UK could not simply operate an entirely independent external trade policy while remaining within that framework.

Agricultural trade illustrates the complexity.

New Zealand’s sheepmeat access to the European market included a large EU-wide tariff-rate quota, and after Brexit that quota was divided between the UK and EU.

The UK subsequently negotiated its own trade agreement with New Zealand, including staged liberalisation of sheepmeat imports.

So there is a legitimate sovereignty question here:

When countries collaborate, does the structure genuinely help each country elevate its own people, or does the structure impose priorities that one country would not have chosen independently?

That is the question SHS cares about.

From the perspective of this investigation, a partnership becomes incoherent when collaboration starts looking like submission without corresponding human elevation.

That is the standard we should apply to every international institution.

Not simply:

“Are we members?”

But:

“What does membership actually do for humanity?”


PARTNERSHIP SHOULD MULTIPLY POWER, NOT ABSORB IT

A good partnership should allow both parties to become more capable.

Britain should be able to trade with Europe.

Europe should be able to trade with Britain.

Britain should be able to trade with New Zealand.

New Zealand should be able to trade with Britain.

The existence of one relationship should not require the unnecessary destruction of every other relationship.

That is the kind of internationalism SHS wants to explore.

Collaboration without capture.

Partnership without submission.

Interdependence without erasing sovereignty.

And the same principle applies domestically.

Government should partner with companies.

Companies should partner with communities.

Institutions should partner with humanity.

But nobody should become the owner of the thing everyone else depends upon.


WHAT WOULD HUMAN-FIRST ECONOMICS ACTUALLY LOOK LIKE?

Perhaps the simplest version is:

Humanity establishes basic needs.

↓

SHS measures and represents those needs.

↓

Government establishes the required provision.

↓

Providers are commissioned and financed.

↓

Workers produce and deliver.

↓

Human beings receive essential provision.

↓

Demand and outcomes are measured.

↓

Quality improves.

↓

The system recalibrates.

The economic system remains alive.

Businesses remain alive.

Employment remains alive.

Innovation remains alive.

Trade remains alive.

But the person is no longer forced to finance every prerequisite of existence individually.


AND THAT IS WHERE THE REAL LUXURY IS

We talk about luxury as though it means yachts, jewellery, enormous houses and expensive holidays.

Maybe the first luxury humanity should recognise is much simpler:

having your basic needs secure.

Knowing you will eat.

Knowing you can sleep somewhere safe.

Knowing you can wash.

Knowing you have access to education.

Knowing that becoming unemployed doesn’t immediately threaten your existence.

Knowing that your child can eat regardless of your bank balance.

Knowing that your contribution can be used for more than keeping yourself biologically alive.

That is not laziness.

That is civilisation.


WE SHOULD STOP ENVYING SURVIVAL

There is sometimes resentment towards homeless people or benefit recipients because they receive support without apparently contributing to the economic system in the conventional way.

But that resentment can reveal something backwards.

Why are we looking at somebody receiving basic necessities and thinking:

“Why do they get that?”

Why isn’t the question:

“Why isn’t everybody guaranteed that?”

The answer to inequality shouldn’t always be:

Take something away from the person who has less.

Sometimes it should be:

Raise the standard available to the person who has less.

That is what SHS means by Human First.

Don’t reduce everyone to the lowest common denominator.

Elevate the baseline.


THE BASIC NEEDS ECONOMY IS NOT THE END OF THE ECONOMY

It is the foundation underneath it.

Once food, shelter, water, sanitation, essential healthcare and other defined necessities are secured, people can use their own economic contribution for everything beyond the foundation.

That is where personal choice expands.

Someone works to travel.

Someone works to build.

Someone works to create.

Someone works to invest.

Someone works because they love what they do.

Someone works to buy beautiful things.

Someone works to start a company.

Someone works to develop an invention.

Someone works because contribution itself gives their life meaning.

Those motivations become more visible when survival isn’t consuming the entire economic purpose of work.


THIS IS NOT ABOUT GIVING PEOPLE EVERYTHING

It is about giving people enough to remain human without having to purchase humanity first.

That is the distinction.

The shop can still exist.

The restaurant can still exist.

The luxury hotel can still exist.

The designer product can still exist.

The holiday can still exist.

The better car can still exist.

The premium experience can still exist.

But there can also be a defined category of resources where society says:

This is too fundamental to leave entirely to individual purchasing power.

And then society builds an economic mechanism to guarantee it.


SHS IS PROPOSING THE MISSING LAYER

Legal rights are one layer.

Constitutional rights are another.

Political representation is another.

But there needs to be an economic rights layer.

Because otherwise every other layer is fighting against an economic reality capable of undermining it.

You can write:

right to dignity

but dignity needs resources.

You can write:

right to life

but life needs food, water and shelter.

You can write:

right to education

but education needs infrastructure.

You can write:

right to health

but healthcare needs people, equipment, buildings and medicine.

You can write:

equality

but equality becomes difficult to experience when access to basic resources is radically determined by purchasing power.

The economic system therefore cannot be treated as some neutral machine operating separately from human rights.

It is one of the mechanisms through which human rights become real.


THE THREE QUESTIONS

So SHS brings three questions into the economic system:

What does humanity need to survive?

That becomes the foundation.

What does humanity need to live well?

That becomes the wider civilisation question.

What does humanity want beyond that?

That becomes the space for individual economic choice, creativity, business and luxury.

Those three things shouldn’t be deliberately confused.

A basic human need shouldn’t have to compete with a luxury for the same economic logic.


FROM SURVIVAL TO CIVILISATION

This is ultimately the experiment.

What happens when government takes responsibility for ensuring that the human being has the foundations required to participate in civilisation, rather than making civilisation itself conditional on the person’s ability to pay for entry?

What happens to education?

What happens to employment?

What happens to entrepreneurship?

What happens to family life?

What happens to creativity?

What happens to mental space?

What happens to crime driven by desperation?

What happens to homelessness?

What happens to people who have spent their whole lives merely surviving?

What happens when work starts financing life rather than existence?

We don’t know every answer yet.

That is why SHS is a prototype.

But we can test it.

Measure it.

Calibrate it.

And improve it.


THE PRINCIPLE

A human being should not have to become economically useful before being allowed to remain alive.

A child should not have to earn shelter.

A person should not have to prove productivity before eating.

A human right should not become inaccessible because purchasing power has temporarily disappeared.

And government should not treat basic human needs as somebody else’s economic problem simply because a corporation happens to be the provider.

The provider can remain private.

The economy can remain productive.

Businesses can remain innovative.

Workers can remain ambitious.

People can remain economically active.

But the foundations can be guaranteed.

That is not the abolition of the economy.

It is the humanisation of its purpose.


POWER BACK TO THE PEOPLE — ECONOMICALLY TOO

Political power without economic power remains incomplete.

A person can theoretically have a vote while having no meaningful ability to access the resources necessary to live.

They can have legal rights while being economically excluded from exercising them.

They can be represented constitutionally while being priced out of basic necessities.

That is why SHS cannot stop at constitutional reform.

It has to enter the economy.

It has to ask what the economy is actually for.

And perhaps the answer has been sitting in front of us the whole time.

People need to live before they can participate.

So let’s guarantee the foundations.

Let government coordinate the resources.

Let companies provide.

Let workers create.

Let people choose.

Let innovation improve the standards.

Let markets exist where markets are useful.

Let luxury remain personal.

But don’t make food, shelter and the other essentials of human life dependent entirely upon whether an individual happened to possess enough purchasing power at the right moment.

Because that isn’t really giving power to the people.

It is giving people permission to participate once they can afford admission.

SHS is proposing something different.

Basic human rights must have an economic expression.

The resources required for basic human life should be organised around human need.

Government should coordinate the provision.

Providers should be paid.

Workers should be valued.

Humanity should receive the essentials.

And the individual’s economic contribution should increasingly finance the life they choose to build beyond the foundations of survival.

Because the objective isn’t to make humanity dependent on government.

The objective is to make humanity less dependent on money simply to remain human.

That is the economic freedom SHS is interested in building.

Not a world where everything is free.

A world where the things that should never have been unaffordable in the first place stop being used as the price of being alive.

…

Great now let’s move on this part of the peoject, write this as we’re providing rhe solution the govenrments were never willing to do, to actually recognise basic human needs in economy, not just legally and not just constitutionally, basic human rifhts need to be recognised economically too, or the whole thing falters. The behaviours of thr eu echo of a dictatorship, classed as collaborations. Apparently the uk was paying 90billions into the eu and only getting 30b back, yet it had to renounce from global trades like lamb from new zealand and more.. that is not a partner, as the goal was for the uk to buy from the eu, not for it to be a own country collabortating with others. Keeo what I said with the intentions I said it with.

I’m currently in social housing and the uk has the freedom from EU’s subjugation to finally create thr leading system that recognises its people. I lesrned today thr uk was paying 90mpounds to the eu just to be part of it, yet the eu capped its own growth, deals, trades and more. The EU as that and from that perspective, it is a dictator that wants submission more than elevation, that’s not a strong system, nor a coherent one, nor a partner, it is someone trying to control a ciuntry, and the eu usn’t even a country, it has no land, it exists oiving off of the land of individual countries, being a abstract concept. So maybe brexit was a good choice, even though the fee was slower travel opportunities and ease in european countries, but at the same time UK has now the possobility to finally show its own individual powers and it’s sleeping on the miriads of solutions and opportunities it could take advantage of, being sovereign of self application. Leadership that honours this understand.

A full breakdast english just ate, this would have cosred at least 12£ anywhere else and I just gor it for free. People qill abuse this opportunity, without making rhe most of it and realising the luxury we are living. Treared as human beings, instead of money machines.

Homelessness is human living, everything beyond it is civilisation living
The money thaf people would spend on food, if held by government to allow people to choose and get free food, the governmenr can finance the providers, meaning companies that produce, just like the governmenr already does for the homeless.
People envy the homeless and benefut earners becahse of the benefit they get without contributing to the social problem capitalism is, yet the homeless doesnt get to experience as much higher standards. So we should learn from their concessions and provide higher standards for it. If the government habdles the money part for all basic needs, then the humsn can work to finance its luxuries, not to fend for self’s sustenance
It doesnt mean eveey shope should be free, but specific items should be
A child should never grow to learn, they need to submit to a system that doesn’t represent them nor advocate for them, in order to eat and have shelter. Those are the main basic needs


Discover more from SHS – Human First Writings

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply



Listen to Our Podcast Here


Subscribe to the podcast

Support the show

Help us make the show. By making a contribution, you will help us to make stories that matter and you enjoy.


Posted

in

,

by

Comments

Leave a Reply