6–9 minutes

Law commission.gov.uk answered, offloading the hot potato of their responsibilities, so we accounted

What a great day to hace solidified my staycay on Earth. They grounded my roots.

Lovely Day – Bill Withers

20 November 2026 | SNW — SHS – HUMAN FIRST | Governance and Ethical Law

I wrote to public bodies on 17 November 2026 with six questions concerning informed consent, governmental authority, freedom of conscience, statutory obligations, alternative governance, financial participation and the means by which a human being can challenge the arrangements into which they were born. I did not claim a legal exemption already existed. I asked who was responsible for examining the proposition, and through what process.

The Law Commission of England and Wales replied. We did not receive an identified route, a named competent authority, or a distinct consideration of the legal reform questions buried beneath the questions about government recognition and treaty arrangements. Instead, the response directed us somewhere else, without identifying where.

The response we received

Good afternoon

Thank you for your enquiry.

The Law Commission is an independent statutory body whose role is to review areas of the law of England and Wales and make recommendations for reform. We do not have authority to determine the legitimacy of government, recognise assertions of sovereignty, negotiate treaties or alternative governance arrangements, or establish financial arrangements of the kind described in your correspondence.

The matters raised therefore fall outside the Law Commission’s remit, and we are not able to identify or appoint an official with authority to consider or accept your proposals on behalf of the UK Government.

You may wish to direct your enquiry to the relevant government or parliamentary body. We are unable to advise which body would be appropriate for your proposals or provide legal advice on their status.

I hope this clarifies the Law Commission’s position.

That is the Commission’s reply as shown in the screenshot we received. The original message and screenshot should be retained as the primary record. The institutional response is reproduced here for public scrutiny; the words in our postscript below are ours, not theirs.

The hot potato: answering the powers they lack while overlooking those they have

There is a difference between saying, correctly, ‘we cannot recognise sovereignty, conclude treaties or bind the Government to financial arrangements’ and saying that every matter raised is therefore outside a statutory law-reform body’s remit. The former is a limit on decision-making authority. The latter is a much broader classification of a mixed enquiry.

Section 3 of the Law Commissions Act 1965 requires the Commission to keep the law under review with a view to its systematic development and reform. Section 3(1)(a) expressly includes receiving and considering proposals for law reform. That does not mean it must adopt SHS proposals, commence any particular project or settle a constitutional dispute. It means that the legal-reform dimension cannot be answered simply by listing powers the Commission does not possess.

My original correspondence asked about mechanisms to challenge public authority and statutory obligations, the absence of an identifiable route for such proposals, and responsibility for addressing potential institutional gaps. Those questions can be distinguished from my separate request for an authority competent to consider SHS’s proposed treaty or financial arrangement.

The Law Commission also publishes a process for submitting ideas for law reform. Its response did not identify that route. We are entitled to ask whether our enquiry was considered as a mixed matter, and why the possibility of a law-reform submission was not even acknowledged.

The organisational lens: how an institution reasons about its own remit

This is where SHS applies institutional metacognition. How did the institution receive the enquiry? Did it separate six questions, each with different legal and constitutional implications? Did it distinguish the power to implement a proposal from the responsibility to consider a proposal for changing the law? Which criteria did it use to conclude that all matters fell outside its remit? What, if anything, did it do to identify a route?

The response suggests what our accountability notice calls scope compression: explaining why the most ambitious requested outcomes are beyond the Commission’s powers, then using those limits to close the whole enquiry. We identify a possible straw-man-like substitution of scope, selective omission, an overbroad conclusion and a procedural form of burden shifting by redirecting us to an unidentified body. We do not pretend that this one email proves ad hominem attack, whataboutism, deliberate dishonesty, corruption or an unlawful breach of duty. Those would be different allegations requiring evidence.

We are concerned about the reasoning, the record it leaves, and whether it reflects a wider organisational habit of treating a complex challenge as a reason to pass responsibility along rather than clarify responsibility within one’s own defined role.

Why this leads directly to Dethrowing the 5th

Our companion discussion, Dethrowing the 5th, addresses a larger question: why does a system built in the name of justice so often organise itself around procedural closure, the risk of self-incrimination and punishment, instead of the most complete and reliable reconstruction of the truth?

We have proposed examining stronger protections for witnesses while they testify in court; incentives for truthful cooperation without indiscriminate prosecution for unrelated minor wrongdoing; independent accountability for lost evidence; carefully defined duties concerning preventable harm; safeguards against false confessions; scrutiny of prison labour and economic incentives; and better measures of whether the justice process has actually protected life.

These are proposals, not claims that all safeguards are absent. England and Wales already has rules for retaining relevant material, witness special measures, and limited inferences from silence. The question is whether these rules, their enforcement and their incentive structures are sufficient. The US Fifth Amendment and its prison-labour constitutional exception belong to a distinct legal system. Our comparative criticism does not make the Law Commission of England and Wales responsible for US legislation.

The Commission cannot be blamed on this evidence for every historical failing of courts, prosecutors, prisons or Parliament. But it is an institution whose defined purpose is to examine and recommend reform of the law. We are asking how that purpose is exercised when the problem presented challenges the structure of legal accountability itself.

We accounted for what the response did — and did not — do

We have prepared a ten-page Institutional Accountability Notice containing the original six-question comparison, the statutory-remit audit, an evidence-graded analysis of twelve argumentative tactics, the Dethrowing the 5th reform questions, the SHS institutional-metacognition test, twelve requests for a recorded reply, and the Commission’s response as an exhibit.

Read the complete document: SHS – HUMAN FIRST | Law Commission Institutional Accountability Notice (PDF, 10 pages).

We intend to preserve this correspondence and examine any subsequent replies, ask for a numbered explanation of the Commission’s handling and published criteria, submit separately framed law-reform proposals, and consider appropriate requests for recorded information. We may explore complaints or collective proceedings if evidence and law support a viable basis. Our public analysis is not a court finding that the Commission has committed misconduct.

The postscript we added

Ps: I will not be following your confidentiality offering under your email. We share its possession as you wouldn’t have sent it if it wasn’t for what I sent, and because under SHS’ governance when an organisation fails to protect humanity, public accointability precedes secrecy, as that’s the exact point we’re trying to bring in our class actions. Justice is truth, not concealment, but your system has forgotten about that. Your responsibility too. If you disagree, I would advice to sue me, as no other thing will stop me. But doing ao will then expose everything else, so not sure how beneficial that is, but feel free to try.

That is my original postscript, reproduced without editing. It is an expression of SHS’s intention to put this institutional exchange into the public record, not a legal determination that any confidentiality notice is unenforceable. Publication must still respect applicable privacy, confidentiality and other legal obligations. The attached response is presented as institutional correspondence, with no unnecessary private third-party information.

Justice is truth, not concealment

When the public asks who is responsible, the answer cannot always be ‘someone else’. Responsibility must be mapped, not merely displaced. An institution can decline a power it does not have and still explain the powers it does have. That is the standard we are asking the Law Commission to apply to itself.

For SHS – HUMAN FIRST, accountability is not about counting who can be punished. It is about what can be demonstrated, what was not considered, why it was not considered, and what must be changed so that human life, institutional honesty and the continuity of humanity are not lost between departments.

We have accounted. Now the Commission has an opportunity to account for its own reasoning.

— SNW | SHS – HUMAN FIRST | Metaphysical Legal Representative, SHS Governance (internal, non-statutory designation)

Legal references: Law Commissions Act 1965, section 3 — https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1965/22/section/3 ; Law Commission, Ideas for law reform — https://lawcom.gov.uk/ideas_for_law_reform/ ; Law Commission, 14th Programme — https://lawcom.gov.uk/project/14th-programme-of-law-reform/


Discover more from SHS – Human First Writings

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply



Listen to Our Podcast Here


Subscribe to the podcast

Support the show

Help us make the show. By making a contribution, you will help us to make stories that matter and you enjoy.

Comments

Leave a Reply