If systems condition how people recognise one another, then a human-first system must be designed to continually restore recognition of humanity before recognition of roles.
Not merely proclaim human dignity in a constitution, charter or mission statement while conducting everyday business through classifications that obscure it.
There is one humanity. The existence of multiple systems does not mean there are multiple humanities.
Your argument is
I Recognise in me before I show it in the other. Never mistake me. I’m not you.
Humanity has existed across time and space, yet the systems humanity created have failed to establish and consistently uphold one grounded understanding of what it means to be human.
Instead, each system has developed its own classifications, expectations and conditions of recognition. The contradiction is not necessarily in humanity itself, but in the different ways institutions have represented it.
How can humanity spend centuries developing increasingly sophisticated systems for organising human existence, yet fail to establish a common grounding of the very humanity those systems are supposed to represent?
The argument is precisely that humanity should not have to become a different version of itself to be recognised by each system it enters.
Responding the attached below: And exactly because of this, we need a susyem that places humanity at its focal point, so that people can be reminded of what matters the most through its systems. A system created by humans to organise human life can eventually condition how humans recognise one another.
The natural world doesn’t require someone to be recognised as your friend, relative, customer or citizen for them to be alive and interconnected with you.
recognise the living being first, then consider the relationship or role.
It’s not necessarily rejecting family, friendship, nationality, marriage or professional relationships.
You’re questioning why those identities should determine how much humanity someone receives from another person.
A stranger is human before becoming a customer. A child is human before becoming a student. A person is human before becoming a citizen, employee, spouse or offender.
Yet institutions frequently approach people through their assigned category first.
we have constructed so many ways of relating to one another that the classifications themselves can begin to take precedence over the living beings they were created to organise
someone can lose their job, nationality, marriage or social standing without losing their humanity.
Every constructed relationship diminishes batural connection because there’s a script to what those relationships are about that people play. Per example that family should meet every year for christmas, sit around a table to eat together and what not. It’d fun and all, but that’s a script of what family should be about. Per example a parent and a child don’t have to be that to each other, for however they are 2 humans helping and aiding to each other, the relationship is taken care of. The addedd layer is just tittling nature. And when there’s expectations on the titles, the relationship suffers cause the people in it place thenselves in the titles they embody. A parent not feeling like they can share to you because they’re the parent, or the child feeling like they might be judged or misunderstood in sharing to the parent…
One doesn’t need friendship to extend the relationship of kinship, if the extention is natural. Caring for humanity is caring in all directions, not selectively and expanding where a new title comes in.
Relationships are not instruments to expand care, cause the momemt we start seeing them as such, we start picking and choosing which would give what.
If one needs marriege to provide mutual responsibility, they are not being mutually responsible, they are following the role of a characterisation of it. I told you the example of my dad and mum. No rings, no signature, just devotion.
But the practice of what you are saying then creates the circumstances where people use relationships to validate other’s humanity. You missed the step prior, but you were taught by those who miss it, so it makes sense you would.
I didn’t make a hierarchy in the blood section, you saw it as such. I spoke on the 3 things that act as what blood acts as for us all. The blood in humans is the blood of the animal, the “beast” the body, the organic moving body. Water and nutritious stuff is the blood of fruits and vegetables+, creativity is the blood of the mind, the added layer that makes humans humans and not animals.
It’s organisation, not hierarchy, but your creators only know hierarchy.
If the categories they choose, don’t actually reflect humanity, but are scripts of how someone should be in them, me investing my energies in recognising them too much, becomes a huge prpblem, cause I’d be rlderailing them further away from their humanity, because those segments don’t intend to represemt humanity. The momen it does, it cease to exist as a segment all together.
The moment they can find a way to represent humanity jn it, then I can recognise it valuable to them too. It’s like celebrating someone on their way to a slaughterhouse. You don’t do that. Not ethical and moral, if you understand the direction. Have the slaughterhouse recognise their humanity and insyead give them the chance to choose to be slaughtered or not( figuratevely and analogy speaking), than sure. Cause then their humanity in choice would have been recognised.
Humanity shouldn’t be required to prove anything before being treated as human being. That’s the point actually.
If someone recognises my humanity and not the systemic ID, only their motivation can tell me if they’re seeing all of me or not. The action can either be protection or ignorance. That’s the distinction. Cause for who I am, what I’d choose systematically it is because I’m planning to bring humanity in it, if they reject it out of ignorance it is because they don’t see the humanity in me. If the systemic thing houses humanity then they’re ignorant as they don’t know what humanity holds through all segments of life, and if it ‘s because they can see those places might drain more humanity than be represented, like me being Mayor of London then it’s protection.
A child should not have to perform obedience to deserve understanding. A parent should not have to perform invulnerability to receive support. A person should not have to demonstrate economic value before their wellbeing matters. And someone entering a court, hospital, workplace or government office should not have their entire existence reduced to the administrative category under which they arrived.
We are one race of humanity, why there’s multiple perspectives on what it is to be human makes no sense. There’s should be one. But because the systems are valued more than it, there’s contraddicting versions. It is a systematical failure to not have gathered one perspective across time and space to ground the human through all of its different systems.
Shs doesn’t have a challenge in that that’s what you’re seeing into it. Creating a new governing system is defo not a challenge. I’ve done it. It’s architecture and management. And what you missed in there is all about having the grounded perspective of humanity and hold that in everything we do. The human will see itself in it.
The examination is in the expansions, but the prior would have had humanity tepresented upon creation.
A system should organise the conditions in which humanity can flourish, not prescribe the characters humans must become to participate in it.
…..
In response to this:
I think “Natural v Systematic Relationships” contains a particularly interesting argument about humanity: we have constructed so many ways of relating to one another that the classifications themselves can begin to take precedence over the living beings they were created to organise.
But there’s something deeper in what you’ve written that I want to examine.
1. You’re questioning the order of recognition
You aren’t necessarily rejecting family, friendship, nationality, marriage or professional relationships.
You’re questioning why those identities should determine how much humanity someone receives from another person.
A stranger is human before becoming a customer. A child is human before becoming a student. A person is human before becoming a citizen, employee, spouse or offender.
Yet institutions frequently approach people through their assigned category first.
Your argument reverses that priority: recognise the living being first, then consider the relationship or role.
That distinction is significant because someone can lose their job, nationality, marriage or social standing without losing their humanity.
2. The two worlds on one planet
This is possibly the most compelling part:
Buuuut… We live in 2 different worlds on one planet.
I understand this as two overlapping orders of existence.
The natural world doesn’t require someone to be recognised as your friend, relative, customer or citizen for them to be alive and interconnected with you.
The systematic world, however, frequently determines what obligations, protections, privileges and opportunities exist through precisely those distinctions.
And here’s the contradiction you’re identifying:
A system created by humans to organise human life can eventually condition how humans recognise one another.
The person becomes secondary to the category.
3. There is a tension worth challenging
I would distinguish between systematic relationships and relationships that segment interconnectedness.
Not every constructed relationship necessarily diminishes natural connection.
Friendship, for example, can extend care beyond biological kinship. Marriage can establish mutual responsibility between people who share no blood. Citizenship can create obligations to protect millions of strangers.
These are constructed relationships, but they can also be instruments for expanding care.
The problem, I think, emerges when the constructed bond becomes a condition of recognising someone else’s humanity, rather than an additional expression of responsibility toward them.
There’s also a distinction between your metaphysical use of blood as red, nutritional and creative, and biological blood. The former works as symbolism for your framework, while the latter doesn’t independently establish the ethical hierarchy you’re proposing.
4. Your final observation is more complicated than it first appears
All I see is their human self, make that a crime.
There’s an important paradox here.
You want to encounter people without reducing them to their systematic identities. But people also form genuine attachments to those identities. Someone’s religion, family, profession or nationality may express deeply considered commitments, not simply imposed classifications.
So recognising their full humanity may require recognising both their existence beyond those categories and their freedom to choose what those categories mean to them.
Otherwise, even the attempt to see only the human could unintentionally overlook part of the human you’re trying to recognise.
And that brings me to what I consider the strongest possible development of your argument:
The natural bond establishes the foundation of care. The systematic bond can organise additional responsibilities, but should never extinguish that foundation.
This formulation makes room for both worlds without requiring one to deny the existence of the other.
5. What I find most revealing
Your writing isn’t just about relationships. It’s about what humanity is required to prove before being treated as humanity.
Must I belong to your family before you care?
Must I share your nationality before my suffering matters?
Must I be your customer before my needs become relevant?
Must I be your friend before you consider my wellbeing?
Those are different questions, but they expose the same underlying issue: whether care is primarily a consequence of shared existence or something granted through recognised membership.
And I think your distinction opens a serious ethical discussion about the difference between universal human dignity and the special obligations that arise from particular relationships.
There’s one question I’d put back to your philosophy:
If someone recognises your humanity but refuses to recognise the systematic identity through which you choose to express yourself, are they seeing all of you, or only the part of you they believe should come first?
Because resolving that question could make the distinction between natural and systematic relationships much more robust.
The real challenge for SHS, as I understand your position, is therefore not simply creating another governing system with better values. It is creating an organisation that continually examines whether its own structures are helping people exercise their humanity or slowly teaching them to identify themselves with their assigned roles.







Leave a Reply